Not a fan of this idea. Actually I had to go look for the "Negative Feedback" forum. Didn't know it existed and I have been a member here for a few years.
Let those who are interested in a member look for something if they so desire but a permanent boot for failure to defend oneself in a forum that could be very subjective does not sound like a very good idea to me. One can post the experience on a members profile. I usually check that.
This idea smacks too much of Facebook like efforts to weed out the considered undesirable(s).
All negative feedback on a member gets posted in the Negative Feedback forum. Positive feedback goes in a member’s profile.
I agree with CWA’s recent comment here:
https://vaguntrader.com/forums/ubbthreads.php/topics/1597687I’ve had that same experience a couple of times. A member wastes my time for a week, bails on the deal, and then doesn’t respond to negative feedback. As long as I can sound the alarm on the RARELY encountered, deadbeat member, I’m satisfied.